Older Archived Reviews
This is an older archived review. The Search Feature on this page may not work. To search this site, please return to our Home Page and try your search from there.
*** Come Back Inn
909 Swan St.
This cozy little place is hardly a secret ... its reputation has spread far and wide among the city's knowledgeable food lovers.
But on first glance, a first-time visitor to Come Back Inn could certainly be excused for failing to anticipate its surprisingly tasty and affordable Italian-American fare and friendly environs.
Located in one of Louisville's more interesting urban neighborhoods, the northern tip of Germantown-Paristown - a mix of light industry and well-kept shotgun houses in a few compact blocks that look a lot like blue-collar Chicago - it looks pretty much like any other urban neighborhood saloon.
But unlike most Louisville neighborhood saloons, this one houses a family Italian spot that wouldn't be out of place in Chicago or Brooklyn ... and that's a compliment.
What's more, while Come Back Inn certainly hasn't forgotten its blue-collar roots and qualifies in every reasonable way as a local watering hole, it's dressed up just enough to be reassuring to visitors from outside the nabe. Two large rooms - a smaller front room with a beautiful antique bar and back bar, tall tables and stools, and a larger, comfortable back room, separated by an open arch, chockfull of booths and heavy wood tables - can accommodate a fair-size crowd, and usually do. A gallery of old Louisville photos and shots of famous local and national figures (along with a few strategically placed neon beer advertisements) highlight the wood-paneled walls. There's no non-smoking area in this bar setting, but good ventilation (and air-conditioning cranked up high) keeps the air surprisingly fresh.
Come Back Inn brings just about everyone together in hungry harmony - business types in shirt and tie, worker types in denim, gimme caps turned backward; housewives and retirees and the postman on his rounds.
They all come for the hearty, affordable Italian-American fare, and believe me, it fits both criteria. I don't believe anything on the menu is over $10, and most items (antipasti, soups, panini sandwiches, pizzas and entrees) are around $5 or $6. There's full bar service, and the mostly Italian or Italian-style winelist, while short and limited to everyday table wines, is rationally marked up, with few wines going for more than $15 a bottle.
We didn't hit a disappointing note on either of two visits. The trademark Chicago-style Italian roast beef sandwich ($4) was perfect: A generous ration of thin-sliced, well-done roast beef was piled high on a hoagie bun, then set swimming on a shallow oval plate filled with gently spicy broth; a topping of Provolone cheese (35 cents) made it perfect. There's no lifting this sandwich -- it's soul-comforting knife-and-fork fare -- and yes, it's supposed to be soggy.
A daily special chicken club sandwich ($5.50) included a crisply grilled boneless chicken breast with lettuce and tomato on a toasted bun; it was more than enough for one, and came with a generous portion of what may be the best French fries in town, crunchy-crisp on the surface, mealy and steaming within, dusted with delicious herbs and spices.
On another visit, a single appetizer order of Italian won tons ($2.50) brought two fat ovals larger than golf balls, stuffed to bursting with melted mozzarella cheese studded with herbs and bits of prosciutto, fried golden-brown and remarkably grease-free; the accompanying marinara sauce was chunky and deep in flavor, combining long-simmered tomato sauce and herbs.
A bowl of linguine with Bolognese sauce ($5.50) was another delight, although it might have been more suited to a cold winter night than a simmering Louisville summer afternoon. A sizable bowl bore a huge portion of al dente pasta - it looked more like fettuccine than linguine to me, but that's picky - topped with a generous portion of lightly spicy tomato sauce and dense, flavorful chopped meatballs and a good ration of grated Parmesan. On the side, looking like nothing so much as an oversize cigar perched on a big ash tray, came a light, crusty bread stick lightly coated with herb butter. Perfect!
Come Back Inn reportedly has good desserts, but we never seem to have room to try them after these gargantuan portions. A hearty lunch for two on one visit was just over $21 plus tip; a solo return visit yielded a lunch large enough to fill me and a takeout box for $10.54 plus tip. $$