Kaelin’s is back, and it’s got cheeseburgers!
Well, let’s parse that a little: Meet the new 80/20@Kaelin’s. It’s not like the old Kaelin’s, but it’s certainly rooted in the mystique of the beloved old eatery at Speed Avenue and Newburg Road.
The original Kaelin’s was a Louisville favorite for most of the past century, family-owned from 1934 until its family owners sold the business in 2004. Owner Carl Kaelin was allegedly inspired to invent the cheeseburger on a brisk October day in 1935. (This may sound like an urban legend, but if Kaelin wasn’t likely the first human to put cheese on a burger, his bragging rights to having coined the name and placed it on a menu seem well established.)
The restaurant sputtered along for a while as Kaelin’s, and later as Mulligan’s, but it closed after a few years and remained vacant until partners Chris Fenton, Bill DuBourg, and Matt Staggs bought the building and undertook a major rehab. The dramatically renovated 80/20@Kaelin’s opened last month and appears to be drawing capacity crowds nightly. The name Kaelin’s pays homage to the old place; 80/20 represents the lean-to-fat ratio in a good hamburger.
The new Kaelin’s certainly has burgers. You’ll find eight on the appetizing menu, ranging in price from $12 (for a black bean burger) to $16 (for a fancy beefburger made with a New York strip steak, tri-tip and sirloin blend).
The menu also features a load of apps, soups and salads (from $6 for heirloom tomato and watermelon gazpacho to $16 for the slider trio of the week). There’s also a slate of bistro-type entrees that range from $17 (for a dark-meat fried chicken plate) to $22 (for a prawn and crab cake).
The makeover has retained a neighborhood bar feel, but expansive new floor-to-ceiling windows at the rear open the main dining room up to a light and airy space; the now connected house next door adds a warren of rooms, each with its own style. The cozy bar room is likely to become a favorite gathering place, with its long U-shaped bar that serves both the room and the comfortable front-porch patio. A comprehensive adult-beverage list includes abundant bourbons, fair selections of wines, mostly local beers and house cocktails. I enjoyed a well-drawn draught Guinness ($6).
We found our way to the upstairs ice cream parlor room, a pretty, bright room with a ’50s feel, turquoise booths and an old-style bicycle hanging over the mantel.
Three appetizers got us off to a great start: Fried green tomatoes ($7) are cut into bite-size pieces and deep-fried in a coarse, crunchy cornmeal batter. They’re served with choice of crispy country ham strips or meat-free shiitake bacon, with a tangy buttermilk-dill dip. Hush puppies ($6.50) gained a spicy kick with jalapeños and grilled corn, enhanced by a creamy-spicy piquillo pepper dip. Lollipop drumsticks ($8) were meaty and flavorful, almost gamey, sizable balls of tender drums with crisp skin.
The 80/20 burger ($14.50), heir to the Kaelin’s original cheeseburger, pictured at the top of the page, was exceptionally tasty. Made from three cuts of beef ground in-house, it was juicy and flavorful, hot-pink medium-rare as ordered. The pretzel bun showed grill marks. Dressings were unexceptional: A halved yellow tomato slice, a rather tough ring of raw onion, a couple of small pieces of ghost-pepper bacon, barely piquant despite the pepper’s fierce reputation, and thin yellow aioli-like 80/20 sauce. It was such an ample sandwich that it couldn’t easily be picked up and eaten; better to deconstruct it with knife and fork.
A side of collards ($3) was disappointing, a lump of long-cooked leaves flavored with a couple of small cubes of mystery meat. Fries were better, crunchy and hot, a bit on the salty side.
From Kaelin’s entree list, pan-seared ravioli ($18) was an interesting meatless option. An idiosyncratic variation, it was constructed from two large pasta triangles sandwiching, rather than enclosing, a seasonal vegetable filling that currently consists of neatly cubed pink beets in a thick sweet-potato Parmesan broth that also decorated the plate, topped with peppery arugula leaves and a nest of fried thin pasta strips.
Desserts, made in house, were amazing, and served in large portions. A bourbon-brown sugar tart ($9) was rich and dense, topped with a crunchy oatmeal cookie crust and lightly browned cinnamon meringue, and decorated with pretty dabs of orange, red and yellow carrot marmalade. Spiced chocolate panna cotta ($9) was creamy and light, subtly flavored with espresso syrup and topped with brown-butter white-chocolate crumbles, smoked maldon salt and airy cinnamon whip.
Dinner for two was $70.49, plus a $15 tip for our cordial and competent server, Abigail.
Robin Garr’s rating: 86 points
Noise level: The large venue has several rooms with varying sound levels. We dined in the Ice Cream Parlor, a relatively quiet environment; the bar would likely be much louder (Average sound level 64-72 dB.)
Accessibility: The main floor and rest rooms are easily accessible to wheelchair users. An elevator gives access to the upper floors.